For their final task as sorority pledges, three girls must tell the scariest story they know. Once they finish, the votes are in. But has someone taken murder to heart?For their final task as sorority pledges, three girls must tell the scariest story they know. Once they finish, the votes are in. But has someone taken murder to heart?For their final task as sorority pledges, three girls must tell the scariest story they know. Once they finish, the votes are in. But has someone taken murder to heart?
Holly Madison
- Stephanie
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Christina Rosenberg
- Amber
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
- (as Lola La Belle)
Nicole Zeoli
- Roxy
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Najarra Townsend
- Brianna
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Angela Nicholas
- Brianna's Mom
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Wesley Stiller
- Greg
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Alyssa Price
- Megan
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Sara Jean Underwood
- Tracey
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Christina Iannuzzi
- Brittney
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Jessica Rizo
- Tiffany
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Ashley Noel
- Brandi
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Jean Louise O'Sullivan
- Haley
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
- (as Jean-Louise O'Sullivan)
Stephanie Sanborn
- Phoebe
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Jessica Noboa
- Tonya
- (segment "Sorority Sisters")
Rebekah Kochan
- Lily
- (segment "DollFace")
Ryan Freeman
- Tommy
- (segment "DollFace")
Kimshelley Lessard
- Sarah
- (segment "DollFace")
- (as Kimshelley Garner)
