Name: Who's My Favourite Girl?
Genre: Short
Released: 2000-10-15
Duration: 16 min
Rating: 5.9
Cast: Ross Wright, Tarek Hamad, Katrina Bryan

A very clever and funny look at a confusing stage in all our lives

Two young Scots boys walk to school and talk about things relating to, well, y'knowthings 'down there'! When they get to school they find that one is offered on by a girl. Despite his nerves his older friend teaches him how to kiss and develops his confidence  but has he really got hold of all the issues that come with this difficult age?

I will hold my hands up and say that I got it wrong. Until recently a different review was on this page from when I had watched this short film back in February of 2002 and I had said that it was 'interesting' and 'funny' but that it failed to deliver anything of any significance. I watched it again today and I loved it and, more importantly, 'I got it'. I can only assume I was distracted the first time I saw this because it is a very good and clever look at 'the change' and it captures perfectly how most of us learn things and who, just when we think we've got it sussed, something else points out to us that we really don't. The discussion the two boys have is well written and the ending (which I wrongly took as some sort of punchline) perfectly shows us that this teenager is not at the end of his journey as he thinks!

Of course it is not perfect and many of my points are still valid from my earlier review, but lets be fair  this is a short film and the requirements on plot and character are not as onerous as in a feature. No, all this wants to deliver is a story about puberty and do it in a clever and funny way. The fact that this was made for £3000 just makes it more impressive - although I am surprised that it has won as many awards as it did.

The two performances are great from both Ross Wright and Tarek Hamad as John and Andy. Each have their little quirks, the elder singing to Kylie tunes while the younger is yet to 'develop' and is taught kissing in a mirror by his storm trooper attired friend. They are friends and family of the director rather than being 'real' actors but they come across very natural and relaxed and they convinced me that they were having a real conversation.

Overall this is not perfect and maybe it is flawed but I think it is well written and (for £3000) very well delivered. McDowall handled it well and I think it is better than many reviews here (including my old one) give it credit for. So if you, like me, just didn't think a great deal of this I suggest you leave it for a while and then rewatch it  you'll find a sharp script well delivered on a budget and a final scene that is not a poor punchline but rather an effective comment in relation to the story that had gone before.

The short form refers to creative works characterized by their brevity and concise storytelling. Unlike full-length feature films, short films have a running time of less than 45 minutes, while TV shorts have a running time of less than 22 minutes.

Benedict Cumberbatch in The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar (2023)

Two young Scots boys travel to school to find that one is offered on by a girl. Despite his nerves his older friend teaches him how to kiss and develops his confidence with surprising results!

The Biggest Movies and TV Coming in September

See which big screen releases you can watch from the comfort of your couch.

Theatrical Releases Coming to Streaming

Get a closer look at these actors from their many TV and streaming series roles.

Streaming Stars, Then and Now

Хто моя улюблена дівчина?

Wigtown, Dumfries & Galloway, Scotland, UK

Who's My Favourite Girl?

Photos

Top Cast10

User reviews4

More like this

Related interests

Storyline

Did you know

Top picks

Details

Box office

Tech specs

Contribute to this page

More to explore

Recently viewed